Originally posted by ap5:So far all of these just sound like Bono and the Edge busking. That’s neither good or bad per as, just underwhelming. These all seems pretty boring. I keep hoping some of these re-imaginings will be fuller band and “rockier”….doesn’t seem to be the case though.
I always thought that if the band were to "reimagine" their songs, they'd be vastly different - and each different from one another. Like it's great that these all do sound cohesive and would be on the same album, but as a result - I have no desire to listen to it. I wouldn't even put it on as "background music" because there's much better "quiet, acoustic, etc." type music that would fit the bill than these.
Compare these two versions of the same song - this is kind of what I was hoping for: