1. Originally posted by ap5:So far all of these just sound like Bono and the Edge busking. That’s neither good or bad per as, just underwhelming. These all seems pretty boring. I keep hoping some of these re-imaginings will be fuller band and “rockier”….doesn’t seem to be the case though.
    I wouldn't say they ALL sound like that, but I would agree that everything we've heard so far is underwhelming - even the ones where there's a little more going on.

    I always thought that if the band were to "reimagine" their songs, they'd be vastly different - and each different from one another. Like it's great that these all do sound cohesive and would be on the same album, but as a result - I have no desire to listen to it. I wouldn't even put it on as "background music" because there's much better "quiet, acoustic, etc." type music that would fit the bill than these.

    Compare these two versions of the same song - this is kind of what I was hoping for:



  2. I have hoping we’d get truly radical re-imaginings of these songs - that are as different as say Wake Up Dead Man was at the time of the Salome outtakes to what actually appeared in Pop. Not a great example perhaps, but that’s taking what was a heavier “rock” song and transforming it into something very different.

    I don’t know. So far these just all seem to…suck the life out of the tunes. I’d love to see them take something like “40” and make it an all out rocker….put “40” into the MoFo blender! It would probably suck, but it would be interesting!

    30+ songs to go, but so far I remain underwhelmed.
  3. I used to frequent message boards back in the day of other bands I loved. And I’d see a base turn on the artist for a moment or a song that was extremely different. I love Aerosmith and I remember the rebellion when they recorded I don’t want to miss a thing or played the Super Bowl with NSYNC. There was this “sell out! They’ve gone soft, this isn’t my band anymore!” Stuff everywhere. And I remember thinking “this will never happen with U2 fans because one of the reasons we love the band is that they change and do things out of character all the time, it’s an ever changing, ever evolving thing. U2 fans are too mature and genuinely smart to be bothered by such petty ideas and close mindedness. But damn it if here we are.. I’m shocked at some of you, and genuinely disappointed in us as a whole. We’ve become one of those “old man screams at cloud” communities 😕
  4. I think it could’ve been an entirely different proposition if all four had gone all in on 20 songs. But having read Adam’s comments about it, it seems very much like it was a Bono and Edge project and so far it shows. I enjoyed the snippets as part of the audiobook, I felt like they added a lot to the experience and it was nice to hear an alternate take on the songs. But so far, the full length versions have failed to grab my attention as much. Still, I’m intrigued to hear how some of the other tracks turn out.

  5. This is the first one of these songs I don’t hate. I like the harmonies really coming out in this clip. Even though it’s acoustic, it’s at least got some pace and some movement and some energy to it, as opposed to the others.
  6. It struck me today while watching the trailer for the Letterman special that, no matter what I think of the songs on the SOS album; what is exciting about this album is that it seems to be the album they wanted to make. Not the album they thought they should make, or needed to make, or made with the aim of staying relevant; or one that embraces the latest sounds. It seems (hopefully) to have been done to please no one but themselves. And I like that. It's what often makes debut albums so appealing. Sure, sometimes it may not pay off but if they're finally ignoring all of the white noise outside of the studio, I'm not gonna complain.
  7. Originally posted by Sydney_MIke:It struck me today while watching the trailer for the Letterman special that, no matter what I think of the songs on the SOS album; what is exciting about this album is that it seems to be the album they wanted to make. Not the album they thought they should make, or needed to make, or made with the aim of staying relevant; or one that embraces the latest sounds. It seems (hopefully) to have been done to please no one but themselves. And I like that. It's what often makes debut albums so appealing. Sure, sometimes it may not pay off but if they're finally ignoring all of the white noise outside of the studio, I'm not gonna complain.
  8. Originally posted by Sydney_MIke:It struck me today while watching the trailer for the Letterman special that, no matter what I think of the songs on the SOS album; what is exciting about this album is that it seems to be the album they wanted to make. Not the album they thought they should make, or needed to make, or made with the aim of staying relevant; or one that embraces the latest sounds. It seems (hopefully) to have been done to please no one but themselves. And I like that. It's what often makes debut albums so appealing. Sure, sometimes it may not pay off but if they're finally ignoring all of the white noise outside of the studio, I'm not gonna complain.
    This makes me sad, though, because it’s driven by just two of them. It’s not driven by U2. It might technically be a U2 album. But it’s not driven by the whole band. It’s driven by Bono and Edge. And they’re great, whatever, but U2 are grounded in their rhythm section. The rhythm section adds so much to so many of their songs. And to have Larry and Adam’s signature sounds and their force neutered, even if they’re not technically completely stripped out, kills the soul of much of the music. So…I’m still not super jazzed about this project. I’d rather them do nothing at all than do something that, as I’ve said numerous times at this point, lacks soul and vitality.
  9. Originally posted by justinpushplay:I used to frequent message boards back in the day of other bands I loved. And I’d see a base turn on the artist for a moment or a song that was extremely different. I love Aerosmith and I remember the rebellion when they recorded I don’t want to miss a thing or played the Super Bowl with NSYNC. There was this “sell out! They’ve gone soft, this isn’t my band anymore!” Stuff everywhere. And I remember thinking “this will never happen with U2 fans because one of the reasons we love the band is that they change and do things out of character all the time, it’s an ever changing, ever evolving thing. U2 fans are too mature and genuinely smart to be bothered by such petty ideas and close mindedness. But damn it if here we are.. I’m shocked at some of you, and genuinely disappointed in us as a whole. We’ve become one of those “old man screams at cloud” communities 😕
    Yes.... it's really unfortunate. But I will also say it that there are quite a number of trolls and " false fans " here who are making the loudest noise.
  10. Originally posted by TRISTAN:[..]
    Yes.... it's really unfortunate. But I will also say it that there are quite a number of trolls and " false fans " here who are making the loudest noise.
    Just because people have differing opinions from you doesn’t make them “false fans”, and it continues to be insulting to a lot of people on this website—including, again, many of the fine people who run this website and have spent so much of their time and energy and money for so long being passionately dedicated to this band and making sure that other people can enjoy them in as many forms as possible—that you keep insisting on this. It’s pretentious and unbecoming.
  11. Originally posted by Hoosier2012:[..]
    This makes me sad, though, because it’s driven by just two of them. It’s not driven by U2. It might technically be a U2 album. But it’s not driven by the whole band. It’s driven by Bono and Edge. And they’re great, whatever, but U2 are grounded in their rhythm section. The rhythm section adds so much to so many of their songs. And to have Larry and Adam’s signature sounds and their force neutered, even if they’re not technically completely stripped out, kills the soul of much of the music. So…I’m still not super jazzed about this project. I’d rather them do nothing at all than do something that, as I’ve said numerous times at this point, lacks soul and vitality.
    It would be sad if they were doing a proper new album this way. This whole project I think was for fun with little at stake so that's how I'm approaching this.
  12. Originally posted by theflytv:Stories for boys has one of they videos to go with it on YouTube now, still only a small part of the song but I must say much better video and something from SOS to actually quite look forward to. It was one of the few songs that sounded promising from the audiobook clips.