1. Originally posted by dstankie:As far as I can tell, rock is dead (and has been for some time). I don't know what to call this style of song, but U2 have been doing it for two decades now. The weirdest thing for this old timer is that the Edge seems to do little but play electric guitar nowadays in ways that sound like lots of other people playing electric guitar. Sometimes this really works (e.g. Red Flag Day). But he used to play like no one else and in fact really go out of his way to deconstruct the electric guitar. Also strange to me: Bono can't seem to move past platitudes and tired rhymes half the time in his lyrics. Take your pick of songs from the first 20 years and try to find anything as uninspired as "I'm free/Where you are is where I'll be."

    To Valentine's point, how can they not see what a diminishment this is creatively?

    I hear all your objections already: at least they're still together and making music... It's not that bad... The bass part is cool... Edge's solo (though it's way too short to be called a solo) has some great energy...It's just a fun song for the Vegas residency...Don't be so negative...

    Thought experiment: Would it really have been better if the Beatles had stayed together and made mediocre albums for the next thirty years?
    For one, I disagree with almost everything you said. Lastly, yea I would have preferred the Beatles stayed together. Because even if they made 5 more decent albums, I guarantee you each one of those records would have at least three great Beatles songs. And I’d rather have 15 more great Beatles songs in my life than not
  2. I don’t think that is Edges fault that the band have opted to go the route they have gone since 2011.

    I think regression is a bit harsh, I would argue he has gotten older (as the band has) and the music hasn’t warranted the same sound.
  3. In turn, I would likewise say its harsh to suggest that their music hasn't warranted an interesting sound....but wouldn't necessarily disagree
  4. Originally posted by dstankie:As far as I can tell, rock is dead (and has been for some time). I don't know what to call this style of song, but U2 have been doing it for two decades now. The weirdest thing for this old timer is that the Edge seems to do little but play electric guitar nowadays in ways that sound like lots of other people playing electric guitar. Sometimes this really works (e.g. Red Flag Day). But he used to play like no one else and in fact really go out of his way to deconstruct the electric guitar. Also strange to me: Bono can't seem to move past platitudes and tired rhymes half the time in his lyrics. Take your pick of songs from the first 20 years and try to find anything as uninspired as "I'm free/Where you are is where I'll be."

    To Valentine's point, how can they not see what a diminishment this is creatively?

    I hear all your objections already: at least they're still together and making music... It's not that bad... The bass part is cool... Edge's solo (though it's way too short to be called a solo) has some great energy...It's just a fun song for the Vegas residency...Don't be so negative...

    Thought experiment: Would it really have been better if the Beatles had stayed together and made mediocre albums for the next thirty years?
    Rock is dead? You’re just not listening to the right bands. Check out the last Queens of the Stone Age record
  5. Originally posted by LikeASong:But as a guitar player myself I can definitely say that The Edge has, indeed, regressed in his guitar playing – both at execution and imagination levels.

    He used to be groundbreaking and have truly memorable parts in terms of sound, composition and purpose to the song.

    Nowadays he's as generic as it gets with his new parts, nothing really sticks out anymore, and he's also been getting lazier and lazier in his playing (Invisible solo anyone?), relying more each time on backing tracks and simplifying some of his older parts.


    Agree. He justifies this in interviews saying that his purpose is to "serve the song" but really he has been doing that with a kind of generic wash of instrumentation - multiple guitar overdubs, multiple backing keyboard parts - so that everything ends up sounding like the kind of background music you hear as walk through a shopping mall. Whereas the first time I heard "Wire" or "Streets" or "The Fly" or "Mysterious Ways" or "Heartland" I was like "Whoa! WTF is that?". Even the guitar opener for "One" is a guitar tone I never heard before that moment. But this last few albums and now this new thing is just the most generic nothing of a guitar sound I don't know how they can't be bored by it themselves. I'm not a fan of guitar solos and I definitely don't find them "sexy" but this guitar "solo" in "Atomic City" is laughably uninventive and he even repeats it.
  6. Hey it could be worse, they could be Kiss and keep rehashing the same tours and setlists every year for 20 years straight. Atleast U2 is still making music with the original 4 members. Some are better than others yes, but what you guys really want from the band? Another Joshua Tree? Achtung Baby? And if they did do another one of those albums, most of you would still complain and compare. This is coming from a fan who first listen to NLOTH and loved the shit out of it. And JT and AB are untouchable.
  7. Originally posted by LikeASong:I went about this in depth some time ago in some other topic, can't find it now. But as a guitar player myself I can definitely say that The Edge has, indeed, regressed in his guitar playing – both at execution and imagination levels.

    He used to be groundbreaking and have truly memorable parts in terms of sound, composition and purpose to the song.

    Nowadays he's as generic as it gets with his new parts, nothing really sticks out anymore, and he's also been getting lazier and lazier in his playing (Invisible solo anyone?), relying more each time on backing tracks and simplifying some of his older parts. And last but not least: the mistakes He's always been sliiightly on the sloppy side of playing but from 2009 he's been making more and more mistakes. They're usually pretty subtle and most of the audience won't ever notice, but for guitar geeks like myself they are pretty obvious.

    Agreed on the changing guitar parts over the years.. it's a guitarist thing, I suppose. Playing more simply or safely is still playing, but it has been quite noticeable
  8. Reasonable rock - atomic city, vertigo, miracle of Joey. Songs with full chords and less interesting note choices or extended solos

    Unreasonable Rock- acrobat, exit, even better. Extended guitar solos with darker vibes and lyrics.

    Nothing wrong with reasonable rock. It’s still rock and better than the lame attempts at pop friendly radio this band has attempted. But I agree this new song does not fit the category of unreasonable Bono has been blabbering about. Then again Bono mentioned Vertigo and Elevation on the e stage as the energy they want this next record to emulate so I guess we shouldn’t expect Achtung Baby again.
  9. The lyrics in this thing are dire too. You can often trace the through-line of a spiritual theme in some of Bono's better lyrics, even in songs where the melody and instrumentation cuts in the opposite direction. But, wow, what a vapid pastiche of empty rhymes. These guys have gotten way too comfortable.
  10. just been listening to this again (or variants of this) - this is what the band needs again: an exciting genre to jam with and see what works

    fuck off with the over-polished safe 'rock'

  11. You read a thread like this on Reddit where people mouth off about how much they hate U2 and how they're overrated, with generic music, generic guitar playing, that Edge is a one-trick pony who over-relies on delay and Bono is overly self-regarding with bland, preachy lyrics and then you realize, oh yeah, I get that now.

    I'm a fan of U2 but one side of me agrees with the worst, least generous criticism of the band and can completely see all of them in this musical turd they just dumped.

    https://www.reddit.com/r/ClassicRock/comments/16jqogz/what_is_a_band_you_hate_that_everyone_else_seems/

    It's all true.
  12. well, it's true, but i liked the song lol