1. Everyone is just mad they didn't get what they wanted in the new song. We're you expecting another Fly or Zoo Station in a kids movie?
  2. For goodness sakes people! These four 60-61 year old men we’re talking about! Y’all talking about another Vertigo or Where The Streets Have No Name. I preferably don’t want another one of those songs. The songs we got in the past are great to me. If this song is a taste of what the new U2 album will be like when it eventually comes out, I’m good with that.
  3. Btw, this is a beautiful song and I’ve dedicated it to my wife
  4. So funny to see people arguing opinions here. Some things never change. I think this song is shit. Doesn’t mean someone else can’t say it’s a top tier u2 song.
  5. Originally posted by MoFoNYR15:So funny to see people arguing opinions here. Some things never change. I think this song is shit. Doesn’t mean someone else can’t say it’s a top tier u2 song.
    A lot of it is just discussion as long as nobody is trying to claim there opinion is fact or that someone else’s opinion is inferior then I think conversing is ok. Fine lines at times I guess between people just stating an opinion and being overly critical or overly defensive of the song but seems ok if it doesn’t get personal.
  6. If only someone had given them an Oscar for Hold Me, Thrill Me or Stay… or even Ordinary Love. Then we wouldn’t be in this mess. I propose we give them one for either of the first 2 (25+ years after the fact admittedly) & hopefully they’ll delete this dire song & we can all rewind 24 hours to that time of blissful ignorance…those halcyon days before this rubbish was heard by my ears.
  7. Originally posted by Reach1985:If only someone had given them an Oscar for Hold Me, Thrill Me or Stay… or even Ordinary Love. Then we wouldn’t be in this mess. I propose we give them one for either of the first 2 (25+ years after the fact admittedly) & hopefully they’ll delete this dire song & we can all rewind 24 hours to that time of blissful ignorance…those halcyon days before this rubbish was heard by my ears.
    The songs you mentioned fit perfectly with the mood and style of the movies they were featured in, as I'm sure Your Song Saved My Life will do for a sequel to an animated movie about singing animals. Totally fine if you or others dislike the song itself, of course, but just pointing out that there is a reason the song sounds like it does, like any soundtrack song the band has done previously.

    While we're on the related subject, I think The Hands That Built America is one of U2's most overblown, overrated songs of all time. That chorus just does nothing for me. But wow did it pack a punch coming at the closing sequence/end credits of Gangs of New York.
  8. Generic, bland, overproduced, cliché, MOR trash... But at the same time, exactly what I was expecting when I clicked on the youtube link. I'm not even disappointed anymore as I accepted this is the way it is a long time ago.. But it still always breaks my heart to remember what this band used to be capable of.... I often wonder what caused their spark, creativity and adventurousness to completely die off??

    I just really wish they'd hurry up and call it a day so they don't bury their once legendary musical legacy any deeper under the ever increasing layers of crap they've heaped on top of it for the past decade or more....





    *just my opinion FYI
  9. Still baffled that this is being approached as an original U2 song and not a soundtrack song. I’ll reserve full judgement until somebody posts explaining where the song fits in with the movie but it could literally be to narrate a scene for all we know. It is what it is until we know more.
  10. Originally posted by germcevoy:Still baffled that this is being approached as an original U2 song and not a soundtrack song. I’ll reserve full judgement until somebody posts explaining where the song fits in with the movie but it could literally be to narrate a scene for all we know. It is what it is until we know more.
    It’s in the closing credits. I still think the lyrics hold more power taken in the context of an actual person. I don’t see how anyone could overlook the lyrics but because it’s in sing 2 and not got edge on electric guitar it’s not cool enough for some folk. I hope based on the reaction to this and we are the people and in fact going back to SOI even that the band completely ignore the fans. They’re getting no credit for anything they do now, or any credit they do get for anything isn’t in the majority.
  11. Originally posted by deanallison:[..]
    It’s in the closing credits. I still think the lyrics hold more power taken in the context of an actual person. I don’t see how anyone could overlook the lyrics but because it’s in sing 2 and not got edge on electric guitar it’s not cool enough for some folk. I hope based on the reaction to this and we are the people and in fact going back to SOI even that the band completely ignore the fans. They’re getting no credit for anything they do now, or any credit they do get for anything isn’t in the majority.
    Well yes it’s an original U2 composition but surely it must be totally influenced by the movie it serves and not therefore a song that would be made for a U2 record.

    If they put this on an album then I’d be saying it’s as weak as piss but if it’s a track to serve a narrative in an animated movie then surely it can only be scrutinised within that context?
  12. On another note, could the band please have a go at that heavy version of ISHFWILF from the trailer on the next tour please?