Originally posted by MoFoNYR15:So funny to see people arguing opinions here. Some things never change. I think this song is shit. Doesn’t mean someone else can’t say it’s a top tier u2 song.
Originally posted by Reach1985:If only someone had given them an Oscar for Hold Me, Thrill Me or Stay… or even Ordinary Love. Then we wouldn’t be in this mess. I propose we give them one for either of the first 2 (25+ years after the fact admittedly) & hopefully they’ll delete this dire song & we can all rewind 24 hours to that time of blissful ignorance…those halcyon days before this rubbish was heard by my ears.
Totally fine if you or others dislike the song itself, of course, but just pointing out that there is a reason the song sounds like it does, like any soundtrack song the band has done previously.Originally posted by germcevoy:Still baffled that this is being approached as an original U2 song and not a soundtrack song. I’ll reserve full judgement until somebody posts explaining where the song fits in with the movie but it could literally be to narrate a scene for all we know. It is what it is until we know more.
Originally posted by deanallison:[..]
It’s in the closing credits. I still think the lyrics hold more power taken in the context of an actual person. I don’t see how anyone could overlook the lyrics but because it’s in sing 2 and not got edge on electric guitar it’s not cool enough for some folk. I hope based on the reaction to this and we are the people and in fact going back to SOI even that the band completely ignore the fans. They’re getting no credit for anything they do now, or any credit they do get for anything isn’t in the majority.